Maybe the kids are alright

I’ve been fairly quiet on the developments in Egypt, preferring to let others do the blogging, especially when they know far more than I do. (Ethan Zuckerman, for example.) But I’ve been involved in many conversations, because it’s damned interesting, what’s going on. One of those conversations is with my sister Jan, by email. She’s a retired Commander with the U.S. Navy, and a veteran at international matters as well, having served as an exchange officer with the British Royal Navy and as a protocol officer with the U.S. one.

I liked an email she sent this morning well enough to ask her if it was cool to share it. She said yes, and here it is:

I can’t help but believe that at least half the educated and aware (not always the same thing, is it?)  population of the world isn’t digesting yesterday’s outcome without thinking of their own government.  I liked Tom Friedman’s line in his latest column Postcard From a Free Egypt – Hello, Tripoli, Cairo calling. I can feel his optimism and I have it, too.

I don’t think this is going to be nasty to watch; I have been beyond impressed with the control the protestors have displayed in this process, and I just realized why:  Facebook may have gotten them into the Square, but it was Twitter that kept them in hand.  This was not the protest of the bullhorn, of the warping of direction by misinterpretation caused by passing the word along because the word was universally available in one shot! The age of reiteration is over.  Now is the age of the direct thought going out to all ears vs the age old chain of mouth to ear to mouth to ear….  That is the power of Twitter.

So the message and the method stayed true.  No one went off the rails, the whole thing was non-violent in intent and in execution. And – the hitherto unimaginable – the youth stayed true to that.  Youth, who we associate with hooliganism in sports and overheated loyalty to their current cultural idols, they kept their eye firmly on the long-view.  They led their elders – the professionals who had lived under the thumb and threats of a tyrant, the educated who were stifled and stilled by fear, the political who were passively waiting.  The youth led, because they had a unity of purpose that was tightly held — or in this case twittered.

Today I am stunned, and smiling, and … wondering.  Do our politicians realize that we, too, have an enormous disenfranchised population?  That we have a large, youth-filled population who feel they have few options or opportunities? That we have an underclass in living in a poverty that should be unimaginable in a first-world country?  That we have an eager and interested population that feels its voice cannot be heard by our government over the cacophony of corporate interests?

And this is not the voice of the Tea Party.  I think it will become glaringly obvious  that the Tea Party was a just a segment of the frustrated, found to be useful to and thereby fueled and funding by special interests, enlarged by bored and lazy media and will eventually be fragmented by electoral fulfillment.  The population I’m thinking of has not been heard from yet.  The Administration may think that Organizing for America gives them a voice, but it hasn’t, because it is too one-way.  It is a fund-raising, message passing tool of the administration.

The voice heard in the square in Cairo and in the streets of Egypt did not rise up overnight or out of thin air.  That voice that has been unheard because it was a voice shouting in a vacuum.  But a vacuum cannot exist in cyberspace. Traditionally in revolutions the key is to take over the one-to-many vehicles of mass communication, radio and TV.  But this time they were not taken over, they were ignored.  They weren’t needed because it was the masses that were communicating.

So now we are in a new age, an age of leadership and governments being held accountable to the voice of the governed.  And in this new age I am optimistic for Egypt as well as other oppressed people.  I hope every autocrat and dictator is hearing footsteps in the dark.  And I hope our government is paying close attention — people have voices and, no matter how disenfranchised, they have just learned a new way to make them heard.

Bonus link.

[Later…] While this post has met with a fair amount of approval here and in the Twitterverse, Doug Skogland has some pushback.

Perhaps linking to this piece by Nicholas Kristof will help.

This entry was posted in Family, Geography, Journalism, Places, Politics. Bookmark the permalink.

12 Responses to Maybe the kids are alright

  1. Pingback: Tweets that mention Doc Searls Weblog · Maybe the kids are alright --

  2. Paul Budde says:


    Thanks for this blog. When reading this I thought that the Wikileaks exposed the thought processes of our ‘elders’ and indeed how different that is from a generation that works in a much flatter society where we talk to each other rather than about each other. And look how aggressively they opposed to this exposure.

    What we have to do is to use our modern comms to link like-minded minds and work together to make the improvements that we as a global society so drastically need across many aspects: hunger, education, health, environment.

    I sincerely hope that all of these ‘springs’ are leading to a different summer for all of us.

    Paul Budde

  3. Dave Winer says:

    I haven’t had that experience with Twitter. There’s a quote going around with my name on it, on Twitter, about Twitter. It isn’t what I said, and I don’t agree with it. If someone else had said it, I would disagree with them (and think they were stupid and sappy and inexperienced). It’s as bad as any misquote by a lazy reporter. It’s proven impossible to quash. The people who are repeating it don’t mean to misquote. They *like* what they think I said.

    Twitter is like word of mouth and it can be perverted in the same way.

  4. Dave Täht says:

    Obviously the Egyptian government missed the memo about how to use COINTELPRO techniques.

    Yes, I’m cynical. As for what happened to the Tea Party, and many other reform movements in the USA – entryism also applies.

  5. Pingback: P2P Foundation » Blog Archive » The end of the vacuum: the larger implications of Tunisia and Egypt for the whole world

  6. Euan says:

    Great post Doc and Jill has put her finger on what is interesting about this. I have been saying the same about those in power inside organisations in a comments conversation over on Facebook.

    I don’t think your experience Dave negates her point. Wasn’t it you who said once that not liking blogging was like not liking the telephone – or something like that. The fact that Twitter can be used for bad things doesn’t mean it can’t be used for good but at the end of the day it is down to what people do with the tools rather than the tools themselves.

    Say hi to Jill for me Doc

  7. Euan says:

    And apologise to Jan for me calling her Jill!!

  8. Trudy W Schuett says:

    Powerful stuff. *Hopeful* stuff. I think everybody needs that right now.

  9. Terry Heaton says:

    Smart lady, that one. Ex-hippie, no doubt (and I say that with a knowing smile).

  10. Crazy Eddie says:

    That was one incredibly powerful email from your sister. It’s more astute than most of the stuff I’ve read in the media. Thank you, thank you, so much for sharing it. I widh more could read it.

    Spirit Village Review

  11. Pingback: Ägypten: “Mass media weren’t needed because it was the masses that were communicating.”

  12. Pingback: Is The Egyptian Revolution Dangerous For Youth? | Homebrewed Theology

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *