What the Internet Isn’t, and How to Get Privacy There

The incorporeal non-place where we also live. By Hugh McLeod, 2004.

Data Minimization is Imperative for the Age of AI Agents is a new essay in Tech Policy Press by Bruce Schneier and Brett Frischman that makes a bunch of important points. I agree with all of them, except for the opening line: “Surveillance is the business model of the internet.” This is a one-liner that Bruce has explained and popularized well. I should add that Bruce and Brett are both friends of mine, and that I agree with the rest of that paragraph—

Personal data drives the advertising industry, which in turn drives the surveillance economy. This data is exploited in other ways as well, ranging from personalizing social media feeds to training AI. Curbing industry’s use of our data is essential to solve the problems of engineered addiction, manipulation, and decaying democracy. We failed to regulate surveillance in social media; we have a limited chance to make a different choice with AI agents. We need robust data minimization rules for AI agents.

—along with the rest of the essay. Please read it. And let me explain both why I have trouble with that one-liner and how I believe we can defeat surveillance online.

Start here: the Internet has no business model, any more than gravity and human speech have business models. It’s too deep and basic for that.

As  David Weinberger and I explained in World of Ends, the Internet at its base—what makes everything on it possible—is a communications protocol: “an agreement about how things work together.” Specifically,

This protocol doesn’t specify what people can do with the network, what they can build on its edges, what they can say, who gets to talk. The protocol simply says: If you want to swap bits with others, here’s how. If you want to put a computer — or a cell phone or a refrigerator — on the network, you have to agree to the agreement that is the Internet.

It is also, as David Isenberg explains in The Rise of the Stupid Network, stupid. As in dumb. Oblivious to what’s on it. By design.

That design holds together a network of networks. Some of those are businesses that charge for access to the Internet, or (in the case of mobile phones) for limited sums of data (which most of us never reach). And most of the activity on the Net is 6.3 billion people doing stuff: accessing websites, exchanging messages and email, watching videos, listening to podcasts, consuming and producing many forms of content, and otherwise living their digital lives. They do pay for a lot of that stuff, but that’s about the suppliers’ business models. Not the Internet’s.

This is not to say that surveillance isn’t a problem on the Internet. It’s gigantic, and I have been fighting it for decades. (People vs. Adtech lists 162 pieces I’ve written or co-written, including The Cluetrain Manifesto, posted in 1999.) And with little success. Advertising today is a $1.08 trillion fecosystem that includes your TV and your car. Both are built to spy on you, so you can get very personalized advertising. AI, working on their side, is only going to make the whole thing shittier than ever.

In Let’s not make the same mistakes with AI that we made with social media (MIT Technology Review, March 13, 2024) Bruce Schneier and Nathan E. Sanders make an important point about tools for government intervention:

The single biggest point of leverage governments have when it comes to tech companies is antitrust law. Despite what many lobbyists want you to think, one of the primary roles of regulation is to preserve competition—not to make life harder for businesses. It is not inevitable for OpenAI to become another Meta, an 800-pound gorilla whose user base and reach are several times those of its competitors. In addition to strengthening and enforcing antitrust law, we can introduce regulation that supports competition-enabling standards specific to the technology sector, such as data portability and device interoperability. This is another core strategy for resisting monopoly and corporate control.

There is another body of law we can also use to protect our privacy: contract. Plenty of laws are already on the books. We don’t need more of them. We—you and I—need only to be the first parties in privacy agreements we make with the sites and services of the world. “Consent,” as we see with every insincere cookie notice, is a gigantic fail.

This is why I led work on a new standard published this last January:  IEEE 7012-2025—Standard for Machine-Readable Personal Privacy Terms. Its nickname is MyTerms, much as IEEE 802.11 is nicknamed Wi-Fi. With MyTerms, you proffer a term picked from a limited roster on a public website. The site or service agrees to that term, or to one of the others on the roster that the first party finds agreeable, and both parties record identical records of the agreement. The standard also specifies the need for machine agents on both sides. These can be as simple as browser and Web server plugins, or as complex as AI agents on both sides.

We created Customer Commons to hold the roster of terms. The idea was for Customer Commons to be for personal contracts what Creative Commons is for personal copyrights.

Our strategy right now is not to go straight after the surveillance fecosystem. That’s a deep red ocean. Instead we’re going after a big blue ocean: the hundreds of millions of websites and services that have no interest in spying on people and would be glad to respect personal privacy as a base condition for doing business. And then to start proving in the digital world what we take for granted in the natural one: that free customers—ones in charge of their own privacy—are more valuable than captive and spied-on ones.

When millions of sites and services that truly care about personal privacy say “MyTerms Accepted Here,” then we can start to obsolesce spying as a practice, because respected customers will be better sources of useful personal data—and better partners—than the surveillance-fed guesswork mills can ever provide or support.

So this is a big “yes and” to what Bruce, Brett, and Nathan wrote. And an appeal for help with sailing MyTerms ships into the blue ocean.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *